A few quck notes on my online reading. Ann Kirschner, academic and writer, wrote an interesting piece on reading habits. Having to read Dickens’ Little Dorrit for her book club, she decided to try out different formats, noticing that we have several options on how we can “read” a novel, having to make a choice among “a multiplicity of forms and platforms and technologies and interfaces”, choice that “could be dispiriting if you are inclined to worry about the death of the book”.
The question that is haunting us today is then “do I love books or do I love reading?”
Her decision to use different formats, namely paperback, Amazon’s Kindle, iphone text screen and an audiobook. She jumped back and forth from one to the other, according to the different reading situation, and tell her experience and thoughts in Reading Dickens Four Ways. Initially there was the paperback edition, the traditional book, with the inevitable nostalgic feeling (“In a book about how the present is haunted by the past, I was confronting my old self through the medium of the physical book, still in great condition, still fitting perfectly in my hands. How dare we think that anything could replace it?”), then the audiobook, which also has a past to remember. It started with audiocassette in the Sony Walkman, then mp3 players, and finally iPhone, which has the advantage of combining together a text and audio version (and also a mobile phone, of course). The audiobook has practical advantages (you can listen to it practically everywhere) and creates a peculiar atmosphere:
“Audiobooks also impose a certain discipline. I think of this as real-time reading: The author and narrator control your pace, and it is impractical to skim ahead or thumb back to another section. For Dickens, so naturally cinematic and plot-driven, that can have a breathtaking effect. It was my good fortune to be listening when Little Dorrit and Maggie spent their long night wandering the London streets. I shivered with them, I shared their exhaustion, and I sighed with the dull relief of returning to the Marshalsea prison”
Finally, there is the ebook, where the iphone seems to win over the Kindle, for easiness of use and for the possibility to highlight and annotate texts.
The conclusion of the piece is that as much as we love books, we love reading more. That is why I dare to agree with Kirschner when she said that “Regardless of format, Little Dorrit seized me no less forcefully today in its indictment of society’s ability to destroy through greed and crushing self-interest”.